On the EDge: No tears for departing Swallow

OPINION – There will be no tears shed for John Swallow, who today finds himself among the common people again.

At least from this corner.

Swallow’s resignation, which took effect today at 12:01 a.m., probably closes the book on a political career that was marked by a couple of wins (he was a member of the Utah House for six years), a couple of losses (he was beaten twice when he challenged Democrat Jim Matheson for his seat in the U.S. House even though he ran in the heavily gerrymandered 2nd Congressional District), a political appointment, and his final win, a decisive victory in his run for attorney general.

Swallow dodged a bullet earlier this year when the U.S. Department of Justice decided not to prosecute charges brought against him for misconduct that included allegations that he operated as a bag man for Jeremy Johnson, a guy facing federal fraud charges who was trying to buy his way out of trouble by paying a substantial amount of money to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid to have the matter settled. Reid, of course, denied it all.

Swallow hasn’t been so lucky, however, as state investigators continue looking into alleged false and misleading statements he made about his personal financial state on campaign disclosure forms filed in connection with his election in 2012.

There are other, more egregious issues in play with the former attorney general, particularly surrounding the disappearance of some vital emails regarding the Department of Justice investigation, that were wiped from his state-issued laptop and computer, his home computer, and other electronic communications devices, that the feds were searching for during their investigation. There are missing emails from every one of the electronic devices Swallow has owned since 2009.

It’s gone, all gone, in a manner so Nixonian it is frightening.

Nixon had his erased audio tapes, Swallow has his erased emails, conveniently lost just before the feds began their probe.

What he forgot, however, is the primary lesson learned from the Nixon fiasco: The cover-up, or perceived cover-up, is worse than the crime, at least as far as the public is concerned.

Swallow and his apologists are trying to shrug it all off.

“Why they’re missing (Swallow’s emails), we don’t know, and I don’t think John knows,” Paul Murphy, spokesman for the Utah Attorney General’s Office, said of the missing emails.

There is reason, of course, to believe that Swallow knows exactly what happened to those emails as he is heard asking Johnson, the man facing federal fraud charges, if there was a paper trail between them during a clandestine meeting at an out-of-the-way donut shop in Orem that Johnson secretly recorded. See that transcript here: John-Swallow-Jeremy-Johnson-Krispy-Kreme-Meeting.

Still, nobody seems to know what happened to the missing Swallow emails.

“I don’t know,” as any parent understands, translates directly into “I don’t want you to know.” It’s one of the first thing kids learn to get off the hook when faced with a truth that could be embarrassing. It is almost always a lie, a deflection of the matter at hand, an insult to the intelligence of the persons upon whose ears the line falls.

I think that, and Swallow’s inborn arrogance, inflamed state investigators and made them bite down harder on the case. I mean, even the governor lost confidence in Swallow, telling The Deseret News: “I can say that if he worked for me with all that’s coming up, he wouldn’t be working for me today.”

Well, starting today, he no longer works for the people of Utah, who swept him into office with 64 percent of the popular vote. Toward the end of his tenure, more than 70 percent of Utahns thought he should resign or be impeached.

That is quite a turnaround by anybody’s count.

Perhaps that is why the lieutenant governor’s office is not holding a special election to replace Swallow, leaving it to the governor to appoint a successor.

Hopefully, Herbert will break the run of misfortune Utahns have suffered in the attorney general’s Office, dating back to Mark Shurtleff.

Perhaps we can have an attorney general who will respect the office, understand that the law applies to everyone and not just the privileged or those of similar cultural or political persuasion.

Perhaps we can have an attorney general who will understand decency and reverse the office’s policy of turning a blind eye to polygamy, as both Shurtleff and Swallow have done, and put an end to the sickening abuses that have gone unfettered, unchallenged, unpunished for far too long.

Perhaps we can have an attorney general who will understand that the pursuit of justice is more important than the pursuit of the law and conduct the duties of office with a humane, rather than political, agenda.

The law is designed to protect and to serve the residents of Utah and not favor some while segregating others.

The Utah attorney general’s office needs cleansing to remove the detritus of the last dozen years, to restore the people’s confidence in its elected officials, to balance a field that has been tilted for far too long.

No bad days!

Related posts

Ed Kociela is an opinion columnist. The opinions stated in this article are his and not representative of St. George News.

Email: [email protected]

Twitter: @STGnews, @EdKociela

Copyright St. George News, SaintGeorgeUtah.com LLC, 2013, all rights reserved.


Free News Delivery by Email

Would you like to have the day's news stories delivered right to your inbox every evening? Enter your email below to start!


  • JOSH DALTON December 3, 2013 at 9:20 am

    CROOK! Serves him right. This wole thing between he and Jeremy Johnson should be written for a Lifetime movie. I don’t think Al Pachino or Robert De Niro would take the role. So it would not make the silver screen.

  • Maggie December 3, 2013 at 9:35 am

    This is pretty scary but I agree with you Ed ,and that does not happen to often !
    It is my understanding that this guy is going to collect a pension from Utah tax payers and that is just wrong as far as I am concerned. We have to find a way stop rewarding these idiots for their bad behavior and I do not care what political party they belong to. I have watched really good people work more than one job to keep their families and pay taxes at all levels and not one penny of that hard earned money should be utilized to support fools like Swallow on any governmental level.

    • Craig December 3, 2013 at 1:08 pm

      Maggie, you’re absolutely correct. However, these politicians are all in bed with each other. Even the newly minted Lt. Governor is not going to pursue any more Swallow related investigations. I would hope that if it can be proven that Swallow was elected based on lies and illegal activities, his pension would be forfeited. But, I’m not holding my breath.

  • DoubleTap December 3, 2013 at 12:42 pm

    Good article Ed, as I was never a fan of John Swallow to begin with. It is too bad that there will probably never be charges filed to prosecute him at all. And of course there was a deal made. People would be foolish or extremely naïve to think there wasn’t.
    Now when will you write an article about ObamaCare and all its failures and Obamas lies? We are still waiting….

  • JAR December 9, 2013 at 4:48 pm

    I have to admit Ed, 50% of the time, your over the top logic wise. This time, you made perfect sense. You saw a terd floating in the water and pointed it out. My hat is off to you on the article.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.